Updated Feb 2021

How to set up marketing analytics

The key to effective learning is to take a pragmatic approach to each question you need to answer

Approaches

Watchouts

Is my website design working?

  • Talking to customers – Direct customer contact gives rich insight, even with unfinished designs. The book “Don’t Make Me Think” has a practical approach
  • A/B testing – For large websites it’s good practice to A/B test proposed new designs vs. the old one
  • Product testing – For web applications there is a strategic question of how to measure progress. Sometimes this can be distilled down to a single metric
  • Delegation – Components developed by vendors like Shopify and Squarespace are heavily tested. Using standard conventions makes it easy for customers
  • Be careful when adding complexity to Google Analytics. Create a separate view to keep it organised

Is my brand advertising working? (top of funnel)

  • Consumer understanding – Who could be persuaded to buy? What is the “Job to be Done” in terms of what you would like to think?
  • Concept and Ad Testing – When customers are shown the concept, do they find it appealing? Is the advertising salient or persuasive?
  • Reach – Has the advertising reached the audience?
  • When evaluating top of funnel performance, click-through rates don’t measure branded impact, and attribution analysis is patchy and slow
  • It’s better to do pre-testing

Is my conversion advertising working? (bottom of funnel)

  • Gross Profit ROI – The value of an eCommerce conversion is not the sales price, it’s the gross profit. Use gross profit as the conversion value for your tags so “conversion value / cost” becomes the ROI metric in Google Ads. It’s important to use figures for profit per product which are as accurate as possible
  • Short learning cycle – Digital advertising has many permutations. The way to learn is to run short campaigns and quickly get results. Record the settings of each campaign, and only change 1 or 2 things each time
  • Google Ads as source of truth – It’s recommended by Google to send conversions to Google Ads (even if you are also sending them to Google Analytics and the accounts are linked). Looking at ROI in Google Ads is more accurate than Google Analytics, and uses the “conversion label” which allows dynamic remarketing
  • Flexible attribution models – Google offers a range of attribution models, such as “last click”. It’s possible to compare the results of different models in the “Model comparison” report, and use whichever works best
  • Correct tagging setup – See 1-page guide to How tagging works
  • If you are dealing with intermediate conversions, like newsletter sign-ups, there is a risk of paying for the wrong clicks. Be sure to track the % of leads that ultimately convert to customers

What is my relationship with individual prospects & customers?

For businesses with higher price points it makes sense to take a “people first” view. The CRM software becomes the heart of the system, and advertising feeds into that. Options include:

  • HubSpot – An integrated solution for managing contacts through the funnel
  • Zoho & EngageBay – Lower cost alternatives, targeted at smaller businesses
  • Pipedrive – A sales driven CRM, focused on managing a pipeline of deals
  • Freshworks – A full small business software suite, which includes CRM
  • If CRM is too resource-intensive consider personalised conversion strategies, including dynamic remarketing and tailored landing pages

What is the relative performance of my different marketing strategies?

  • Pull data into one place – Data can be integrated with tools like Supermetrics or Leadsbridge. These tools support the creation of dashboards, or dashboards can be created in specialist business intelligence tools like Tableau
  • Step by step integration – An approach pioneered by Basecamp is to work in cycles. So rather than asking “how long will it take to get everything we want?” ask “what answers can we get in the next 4 weeks?”
  • When data is combined across sources it assumes the lowest common denominator in terms of immediacy. Therefore it’s best for questions which the individual sources can’t answer

Copyright © 2025